Page 1 of 1

Should I use Susan D 1-4 techniques versu Tutors??

Posted: Thu Jul 15, 2010 8:45 pm
by Cat90
Good evening,

Help please!!

I have been using Susan D (1-4) techniques and I'm worried that I should have use Tutors version instead,

What would you recommend please?

Re: Should I use Susan D 1-4 techniques versu Tutors??

Posted: Thu Jul 15, 2010 9:02 pm
by muminTewkes
Ive used these as well as IPS...I found IPS easier(for me!)to understand :wink: but both have been good-havent used the Tutors though for technique but have for vocab.

Re: Should I use Susan D 1-4 techniques versu Tutors??

Posted: Thu Jul 15, 2010 9:13 pm
by slackmum
This series and a few papers at the end was all we used and seemed to work as DS is starting at GS in September. Mind you if I had found this site before we sat the exam I would probably done a bit more! Still think the technique books are great as they are bite sized so I was always able to get DS to do it.

Re: Should I use Susan D 1-4 techniques versu Tutors??

Posted: Thu Jul 15, 2010 9:52 pm
by Tolstoy
I used the S.D books with DS1 because I hadn't found this site when I started tutoring him and didn't know anything about the format of the actual test. The problem is they cover much that won't come up in the test and they use the standard format rather than multiple choice. With DS2 I used the tutors because it just covers the 21 types.

However when I gave DS2 practice sheets I used the S.D standardised versions first because I felt they were slightly harder and would get him thinking more. I believe that in the second test a couple of questions turn up that are not of the 21 types. They are similar so most children are not fazed by them however DS1 for some reason scored higher than DS2 even though it should have been the other way around. This may have been down to the extra types DS1 worked on or the vocab questions which were the only ones where he had the edge.

Upside is I wouldn't worry about which you used as both are pretty much the same for the 21 types anyway just make sure you practice multiple choice as well.

Re: Should I use Susan D 1-4 techniques versu Tutors??

Posted: Fri Jul 16, 2010 7:52 am
by yoyo123
as long as the technique works for your child I don't think it matters which technique you use