Schools wanting students on appeal?
Moderators: Section Moderators, Forum Moderators
Schools wanting students on appeal?
Hi, I am asking on behalf of someone else and leaving it deliberately vague as any details could easily be identifiable.
I know someone whose child has not got a place at the school of their choice but in my opinion (and their's) the school would be the perfect fit for their child. They would have to appeal against non-qualification but they could argue the case reasonably well (again just my opinion) and there is also another mitigating factor which could apply.
I have 2 questions:
1) Do schools ever (particularly in these cash-strapped days) want the applicant so much (because they agree they would be a great fit and a good student) that they will agree to take them regardless of the views of the rest of the appeal panel? (ie if the panel thinks their arguments are weak but the school likes them)
and
2) Does the panel know where they have an offer? For example if School A is perfect but school B could meet most of their needs (at least on paper) but schools C-F would not, if they were offered School B would the panel be aware and say "but you have B so you don't need A". If that were the case would they be aware if the parents turned down B in the hope (possibly extremely risky hope) that the appeal panel would say C etc do not meet the needs and therefore agree that A would be better.
I hope that makes some sort of sense. I am happy to PM details but don't want to on an open forum because this is not about me so I am very cautious (even though I've been asked to do it) about putting any identifiable details.
I know someone whose child has not got a place at the school of their choice but in my opinion (and their's) the school would be the perfect fit for their child. They would have to appeal against non-qualification but they could argue the case reasonably well (again just my opinion) and there is also another mitigating factor which could apply.
I have 2 questions:
1) Do schools ever (particularly in these cash-strapped days) want the applicant so much (because they agree they would be a great fit and a good student) that they will agree to take them regardless of the views of the rest of the appeal panel? (ie if the panel thinks their arguments are weak but the school likes them)
and
2) Does the panel know where they have an offer? For example if School A is perfect but school B could meet most of their needs (at least on paper) but schools C-F would not, if they were offered School B would the panel be aware and say "but you have B so you don't need A". If that were the case would they be aware if the parents turned down B in the hope (possibly extremely risky hope) that the appeal panel would say C etc do not meet the needs and therefore agree that A would be better.
I hope that makes some sort of sense. I am happy to PM details but don't want to on an open forum because this is not about me so I am very cautious (even though I've been asked to do it) about putting any identifiable details.
Re: Schools wanting students on appeal?
Q1) The IAPs decision is binding on both sides so the school can't admit them.
Q2) The appeal panel could have a copy of the CAF and might well know the allocated school - ours did. However they should not let this influence their decision as they may not know the allocated school in detail.
Q2) The appeal panel could have a copy of the CAF and might well know the allocated school - ours did. However they should not let this influence their decision as they may not know the allocated school in detail.
Re: Schools wanting students on appeal?
I don't think so, if this is the normal point of entry, and there are other appeals taking place.loobylou wrote: 1) Do schools ever (particularly in these cash-strapped days) want the applicant so much (because they agree they would be a great fit and a good student) that they will agree to take them regardless of the views of the rest of the appeal panel? (ie if the panel thinks their arguments are weak but the school likes them)
If it were to happen, it would be entirely outside the appeal process, and there would have to be a legal justification - a temporary increase in the PAN, for example, sufficient for the child to be given a place under the admission criteria. (The school cannot pick and choose which particular child it wants.)
However, in the case of a single (probably in-year) appeal, it wouldn't be difficult for the school either to hint that it would be happy to take the appellant, or alternatively to offer little resistance!
What the panel know about preferences (and offers) varies!2) Does the panel know where they have an offer? For example if School A is perfect but school B could meet most of their needs (at least on paper) but schools C-F would not, if they were offered School B would the panel be aware and say "but you have B so you don't need A". If that were the case would they be aware if the parents turned down B in the hope (possibly extremely risky hope) that the appeal panel would say C etc do not meet the needs and therefore agree that A would be better.
http://www.elevenplusexams.co.uk/appeals/general#a21" onclick="window.open(this.href);return false;
Etienne
Re: Schools wanting students on appeal?
Ok that makes sense. Thank you for your help.
I guess it's just up to them whether they decide to appeal now and whether the mitigating factor is perceived as mitigating by the panel.
I guess it's just up to them whether they decide to appeal now and whether the mitigating factor is perceived as mitigating by the panel.