2011 Results - Compilation Table (GL Assessment)

[Tolstoy]

Agree with that. More people may be inclined to give info if names are left out.

[mitasol]

Due to the level of concern about names I have removed the identifying column.

I'm willing to add birth months and/or reinstate names with the agreement of the member - please post or PM me.

[muddywaters]

It's done it's dusted. I wouldn't want to add date of birth months as the results are standardized and this is already determined in score. Thank you BJOD for original posting of results- I was happy to have names on there but will not be adding to any other data.

Thanks for all the help on here but need to get on with our lives now methinks!!!

[mitasol]

I agree with you, adding the birth month without a raw score is not particularly enlightening but the names didn't add anything to the information and several people had asked for their data to be removed.

[Amber]

Yes I actually asked not be identified but still was so glad to see that go. I am happy to send my son's remaining scores if it will definitely be anonymous - including birth month and allocated school when we get it if it will be of help.

[Tolstoy]

I agree with you, adding the birth month without a raw score is not particularly enlightening but the names didn't add anything to the information and several people had asked for their data to be removed.

Actually I disagree. There is such a marked discrepancy between the STRS scores and the Pates rankings that birth months would help parents make sense of it. Raw scores are the same for all so don't really help.

[aargh]

There is such a marked discrepancy between the STRS scores and the Pates rankings

For your Pates ranking the cohort includes girls and boys. That gives the discrepancy. E.g. several DDs my DD knows are in top 120 for SHS but not in top 120 for Pates.

[Tolstoy]

I am aware the girls are making a difference but that alone won't account for these discrepancies. Two boys getting the same raw score both born in September should when you take out the girls have the same standardised score for STRS as you are removing the same variant? Therefore IMHO it can only be down to the birth month.

STRS don't use rankings so can't be compared to the SHS situation.