My dd was unsuccessful in the selection review STT 117.
The selection review panel's view was that three level 5's in reading, writing and maths can be achieved in the KS2 SATS (this was ticked), however academic evidence does not demonstrate academic suitability for the pupil to be placed in a grammar school(this box was ticked) and therefore the pupil would not be appropriately placed in a grammar school.
I am confused with this.
We had exactly the same!! On both counts.
What other academic evidence did you supply? I have come to the conclusion that a Y5 set of CATs which read like this:
Cognitive Ability Tests (CAT3) January 2014 Year 5
Verbal Reasoning Standard Age Score 119
Quantitative Standard Age Score 117
Non Verbal Standard Age Score 131
Mean Standard Age Score 122
Are what did for us. They like to see high 120's is the rumour? Although this would be top few% of the country!
We had a glowing heads report, and a 1:2 recc.
Are you going to appeal?