So who is your Dorothy?
Moderators: Section Moderators, Forum Moderators
-
pheasantchick
- Posts: 2439
- Joined: Tue Jun 02, 2009 10:28 pm
So who is your Dorothy?
I'm sure I'm not the only watching 'Over The Rainbow'. Who is your Dorothy?
I like different Dorothys (dorothies?) for different reasons. Danielle gives overall good performances, Steph and Sophie have lovely singing voices, Jessica has great actring abilities, Lauren is already competant, and the Scottish one has good charisma as well. Anyone could win it now?
And I was surprised that Steph was eliminated.
I like different Dorothys (dorothies?) for different reasons. Danielle gives overall good performances, Steph and Sophie have lovely singing voices, Jessica has great actring abilities, Lauren is already competant, and the Scottish one has good charisma as well. Anyone could win it now?
And I was surprised that Steph was eliminated.
Lauren or Danielle to win for me. I think they give the best all round performances. I think these two are the ALW's favs with Danielle just pipping Lauren to 1st choice.
Sophie and Jenny aren't strong enough to hold an audience imo - they woud struggle with 8 shows a week. Sophie isn't confident enough on her own she is much better in the group numbers.
Jess - can't warm to her not sure what it is, perhaps it's her facial expressions. I think she tries too hard at times.
Steph is really good too and definitely has a bright future ahead of her but I think she looks too old to be Dorothy.
Sophie and Jenny aren't strong enough to hold an audience imo - they woud struggle with 8 shows a week. Sophie isn't confident enough on her own she is much better in the group numbers.
Jess - can't warm to her not sure what it is, perhaps it's her facial expressions. I think she tries too hard at times.
Steph is really good too and definitely has a bright future ahead of her but I think she looks too old to be Dorothy.
Sorry, but I can't stand Lauren 
She just doesn't do it for me when she sings etc.
I like Steph most and another girl, but can't remember which one. It was a shock when Stephanie went this week, I thought she was one of the strongest contenders.
The little Scottish one (Jennie) is starting to annoy me now, yet I quite liked her to start with.
She just doesn't do it for me when she sings etc.I like Steph most and another girl, but can't remember which one. It was a shock when Stephanie went this week, I thought she was one of the strongest contenders.
The little Scottish one (Jennie) is starting to annoy me now, yet I quite liked her to start with.
am beginning to find them all irritating!! we watch it very much on fast forward (makes it a much more acceptable ten minutes and sail through the dogs) and still the actorly-ness (yes, yes, an absolute prerequisite to musical theatre I'm sure, but ...) makes me cringe even at great speed.
Had a sort of soft spot for Stephanie, she was so into it all.
Jess a bit gallumphing,
don't like Jennie (coy pixie),
r Steph (no neck). S
ophie looks like someone (Susan Sarandon maybe?)
which sort of leaves Lauren.
Or Danielle.
Wish they'd just get on with it though, it does rather drag and thank goodness for a double eviction next week.
But the whole "you dumped her so completely" and sailing off on that moon - how ghastly is that!?!?!
Poor old Lordie simpering on his throne looking thoroughly embarrassed throughout.
Had a sort of soft spot for Stephanie, she was so into it all.
Jess a bit gallumphing,
don't like Jennie (coy pixie),
r Steph (no neck). S
ophie looks like someone (Susan Sarandon maybe?)
which sort of leaves Lauren.
Or Danielle.
Wish they'd just get on with it though, it does rather drag and thank goodness for a double eviction next week.
But the whole "you dumped her so completely" and sailing off on that moon - how ghastly is that!?!?!
Poor old Lordie simpering on his throne looking thoroughly embarrassed throughout.
DD3 likes Jenny. I think it should be whoever can wear these, which featured in the preceding program and could be the Ruby Slippers for the 21st century: http://www.net-a-porter.com/product/48276
Marylou
Don’t think Jenny did herself any favours by admitting (more than once) that she’d never even seen a West End musical and didn’t really appear to know much about them – can’t see that playing well with the Lord, whose whole life has been and is immersed in musical theatre.
Have a soft spot for Steph as her mother sang one of the great dance hits of the 90s, but not sure I really see her as Dorothy. Doesn’t she look just a little bit, well, old for the part?
Have a soft spot for Steph as her mother sang one of the great dance hits of the 90s, but not sure I really see her as Dorothy. Doesn’t she look just a little bit, well, old for the part?
