Progress 8 measure is similar for both schools but yes Newstead gets better results at GCSE but not by miles. Newstead results here
https://www.newsteadwood.co.uk/about-us ... erformanceClass sizes Y7-9 are 32,at Townley, 27 at Newstead
Sciences: looking at the stats it seems girls have to do triple science at Townley and there is no choice. Girls have a choice at Newstead
Latin is a paid for option at Newstead (as is dance, Japanese and Mandarin) but a free option at Townley
Sports: Newstead have lovely playing fields and access to the nearby tennis centre. They have a good relationship to those fitness groups who rent the sports halls to the extent these are offered as free electives in Y10. Less polluted area compared to Townley.
Yes buildings are tired at Newstead but teaching mostly great. DD is very happy there.
Hopefully someone will come and balance this and rave about Townley- they are both good schools.