This can't be right!
Moderators: Section Moderators, Forum Moderators
This can't be right!
I've just read an article online from The Times newspaper which states that only 16% of GS pupils get 3 straight A's at A'level compared to 28% at comps and 38% at indie's. I always thought, overall, that GS did better than any of the schools.
http://www.timesonline.co.uk/tol/life_a ... 871124.ece
http://www.timesonline.co.uk/tol/life_a ... 871124.ece
-
- Posts: 3767
- Joined: Thu Dec 18, 2008 11:12 am
- Location: Berkshire
As only the brightest children stay on for 6th form it is perfectly reasonable for comprehensives to perform as well in A Levels as grammar schools.
In our local comprehensives which perform at best at the national average for GCSE so therefore much worse than the grammars, the sixth forms do much better - so to compare a school, I would always look at GCSE and ignore the A Level results.
LFH
In our local comprehensives which perform at best at the national average for GCSE so therefore much worse than the grammars, the sixth forms do much better - so to compare a school, I would always look at GCSE and ignore the A Level results.
LFH
According to the Daily Mail June 2008:-
"Grammar pupils make up 4.7 per cent of the school population ... "
Assuming a similar number of children attend independent schools then around 90% of A level candidates attend Comprehensive schools. If they didn't get the largest percentage of 3 A's at A level there really would be something wrong with the education system in this country
"Grammar pupils make up 4.7 per cent of the school population ... "
Assuming a similar number of children attend independent schools then around 90% of A level candidates attend Comprehensive schools. If they didn't get the largest percentage of 3 A's at A level there really would be something wrong with the education system in this country
It certainly all makes a much more dramatic story than if they'd headlined it "Education shock horror scandal!! Absolutely no change in proportion of students from different sectors gaining 3+ A grades since 2003!!!":
http://www.publications.parliament.uk/p ... 908w12.htm
"Assuming a similar number of children attend independent schools then around 90% of A level candidates attend Comprehensive schools."
As the above indicates, independent schools then accounted for ~13% of A-level candidates (although accounting for c.25% of sixth form students - what were indies doing instead of A levels in 2002?), grammars for about 7% and comps for 42%.
Back then, about 23% of indie and 19% of grammar students got 3 or more A grades, i imagine both percentages are higher now but probably in similar relation to each other since the other numbers have remained nearly constant.
Mike
http://www.publications.parliament.uk/p ... 908w12.htm
"Assuming a similar number of children attend independent schools then around 90% of A level candidates attend Comprehensive schools."
As the above indicates, independent schools then accounted for ~13% of A-level candidates (although accounting for c.25% of sixth form students - what were indies doing instead of A levels in 2002?), grammars for about 7% and comps for 42%.
Back then, about 23% of indie and 19% of grammar students got 3 or more A grades, i imagine both percentages are higher now but probably in similar relation to each other since the other numbers have remained nearly constant.
Mike
Also - the grammar schools in Warwickshire tend to have large sixth forms. Year 12 at my daughter's school has, I think, about twice the number of pupils as Year 11 so there must be a significant number of youngsters who may not have originally reached the 11+ standard who join then.
Mind you - they do still seem to get excellent A level results!
Mind you - they do still seem to get excellent A level results!
Many of those who join grammars in Warwickshire/ Birmingham etc for sixth form will have happily been at 11-16 comps elsewhere (such as Solihull) and not have taken the 11 plus in the first place rather than being "not up to the standard". This should also be taken into account when looking at the "3 A's" group - my son's year group at his comp scattered to a variety of sixth form destinations including grammars & independents - the credit for his A grades (and those of his friends) does belong at least in part to their earlier schools as well.....a significant number of youngsters who may not have originally reached the 11+ standard who join then.
This sort of relates to this thread & Tipsy's other thread about how many A levels are taken at different schools.
Cambridge has made some offers this year based on 4 A levels - obviously it cant do this where students are only taking 3 A levels! but it rather begs the question as to whether 4 A levels is going to become a requirement of Cambridge over the next few years? Or will it provide different offers for those coming from the high performing schools where 4 A levels is the expectation against those coming from more average Comps?
Cambridge has made some offers this year based on 4 A levels - obviously it cant do this where students are only taking 3 A levels! but it rather begs the question as to whether 4 A levels is going to become a requirement of Cambridge over the next few years? Or will it provide different offers for those coming from the high performing schools where 4 A levels is the expectation against those coming from more average Comps?
Your second idea sounds fairer, but I would be uncomfortable with the idea that a very bright student who could get 4 good grades does not have to try as hard simply because they attend a school with lower expectations. This would also unfairly discriminate against those at higher achieving schools.KB wrote:This sort of relates to this thread & Tipsy's other thread about how many A levels are taken at different schools.
Cambridge has made some offers this year based on 4 A levels - obviously it cant do this where students are only taking 3 A levels! but it rather begs the question as to whether 4 A levels is going to become a requirement of Cambridge over the next few years? Or will it provide different offers for those coming from the high performing schools where 4 A levels is the expectation against those coming from more average Comps?
I know of one comprehensive which states quite openly in its prospectus that most sixth form students do 3 A-levels in Y13, as this is all that is needed by universities and employers... . It also takes students to open days at Cambridge, so presumably the university is indeed prepared to make allowances since most of the visitors will only be studying 3 A-levels?
Marylou