Help with confusing maths question
Moderators: Section Moderators, Forum Moderators
Help with confusing maths question
John's dad picks him up from school every third day. Aaron's mum picks him up from school every other day. If they meet on the first day, how many times will they meet over three weeks?
John's dad picks him up on day: 1 4 7 10 13 16 19
Aaron's mum picks him up on day: 1 3 5 7 9 11 13 15 17 19.
So the days they meet are: day 1, 7, 13 and 19.
However, the answer supposed to be 3 not 4. Does anyone know why?
They did not mention that the first day does not count.
My dd came up with an explanation that since they go to school 5 out of 7 days so in three weeks that would be 3x5=15 days. And in the 15 days there are then only 3 times they meet.
However, we don't know which days the weekend falls on so not tusre what is the right way to approach it.
Any maths experts please enlighten us with your wisdom.
John's dad picks him up on day: 1 4 7 10 13 16 19
Aaron's mum picks him up on day: 1 3 5 7 9 11 13 15 17 19.
So the days they meet are: day 1, 7, 13 and 19.
However, the answer supposed to be 3 not 4. Does anyone know why?
They did not mention that the first day does not count.
My dd came up with an explanation that since they go to school 5 out of 7 days so in three weeks that would be 3x5=15 days. And in the 15 days there are then only 3 times they meet.
However, we don't know which days the weekend falls on so not tusre what is the right way to approach it.
Any maths experts please enlighten us with your wisdom.
Re: Help with confusing maths question
I don't think they are counting the first day as it says 'over the next three weeks'.

 Posts: 682
 Joined: Fri Mar 10, 2017 5:06 pm
Re: Help with confusing maths question
Not a very well posed question IMO.
Are we to assume a standard school week of Monday  Friday?
If so what do the phrases 'every third day' and 'every other day' mean in this context.
e.g. If John's dad picks him up on a Monday he will next pick him up on a Thursday. That much is clear, but when will he next pick him up? 3 days on from Thursday is Sunday, a nonschool day. So will he next pick him up on the Monday or does it mean every 3rd school day which would mean he would pick him up on the Tuesday?
Are we to assume a standard school week of Monday  Friday?
If so what do the phrases 'every third day' and 'every other day' mean in this context.
e.g. If John's dad picks him up on a Monday he will next pick him up on a Thursday. That much is clear, but when will he next pick him up? 3 days on from Thursday is Sunday, a nonschool day. So will he next pick him up on the Monday or does it mean every 3rd school day which would mean he would pick him up on the Tuesday?

 Posts: 1252
 Joined: Sat Oct 01, 2016 6:02 pm
Re: Help with confusing maths question
If you discount weekend days, the pattern is:
John: Mon1, Thu1, Tue2, Fri2, Wed3
Aaron: Mon1, Wed1, Fri1, Tue2, Thu2, Mon3, Wed3, Fri3
So they meet on the first Monday, the second Tuesday and the third Wednesday.
But yes it's a badly worded question.
John: Mon1, Thu1, Tue2, Fri2, Wed3
Aaron: Mon1, Wed1, Fri1, Tue2, Thu2, Mon3, Wed3, Fri3
So they meet on the first Monday, the second Tuesday and the third Wednesday.
But yes it's a badly worded question.
Re: Help with confusing maths question
I don't think anything is wrong in this question. It is 3 times. If they first met on Monday then they will meet every subsequent Monday.
Re: Help with confusing maths question
Badly worded question!
a) doesn’t make it clear if the first day is counted (implies not from the wording. but not clearly)
b) doesn’t specify what day of the week it is as that couldnchange the answer (though by making it over 3 weeks I think they are trying to make it not matter: childncould lose time on checking though).
This is a “timewaster” question type: a diligent child would waste 56 minutes trying to ensure they got it right: sometimes teaching a child that if it looks super complicated, give it a minute, educsted guess, then move on will actually get them more marks than getting entrenched in a question with poor wording.
a) doesn’t make it clear if the first day is counted (implies not from the wording. but not clearly)
b) doesn’t specify what day of the week it is as that couldnchange the answer (though by making it over 3 weeks I think they are trying to make it not matter: childncould lose time on checking though).
This is a “timewaster” question type: a diligent child would waste 56 minutes trying to ensure they got it right: sometimes teaching a child that if it looks super complicated, give it a minute, educsted guess, then move on will actually get them more marks than getting entrenched in a question with poor wording.