Appeal Feedback -Bucks Grammar

Consult our experts on 11 Plus appeals or any other type of school appeal

Moderators: Section Moderators, Forum Moderators

11 Plus Platform - Online Practice Makes Perfect - Try Now
Nibbles
Posts: 36
Joined: Fri Nov 28, 2008 5:30 pm

Appeal Feedback -Bucks Grammar

Post by Nibbles »

Hi,

We had our appeal today I thought I would give a few of my observations on the experience.

Overall I found it was very tough, although the panel were very nice it was still a very bruising experience.

They kept going on about where is the academic evidence, we gave them everything we had as advised by the guidance here including
predicted level 5 SATS, already at 4a or 5 at end of year 5, past VR scores of 125 and 126, 1:1 Headteacher unreserved recommendation, very strongly supportive letter from her year 6 teacher, lots of quotes about the standard of her work and her suitablity for Grammar school from the Head and teachers.

Even after we all this they implied it was not enough. We left them with a good year 5 report, and all her school books which were full of positive comments.

But I still had the feeling they were looking for more, but I can't think what that could possibly be, were we just unlucky with our particular panel or have others had a similar experience?

We did our best but I am left with the feeling that our evidence fell short somehow. I am not looking forward to the letter, I feel a disappointment coming on, but at least its over and done with thank goodness.

There must have been quite a few other appeals by now a comparison with your experiences would be interesting.
Sally-Anne
Posts: 9235
Joined: Wed Jan 11, 2006 8:10 pm
Location: Buckinghamshire

Post by Sally-Anne »

Hi Nibbles

I have sent you a PM.

Sally-Anne
Buckscat
Posts: 18
Joined: Mon Jan 12, 2009 2:41 pm

Post by Buckscat »

Hi Nibbles,

Sorry you have come out feeling so down :( - and fingers crossed for good news for you.

Grief though - I am now filled with horror for my daughter's appeal next week. How can you prove academic ability if predicted and actual SATs scores, school reports and teachers recommendations aren't enough? It was my understanding that the appeal panel were not from an educational background - so how can they say that what you provide doesn't prove academic ability?

Fingers crossed for you as I said....

Catherine
Thanks

Catherine
Etienne
Posts: 8978
Joined: Mon Dec 12, 2005 6:26 pm

Post by Etienne »

Panels tend to be rather good at assessing the evidence - they get lots of practice! At least one member must have a background in education (although this could be as a governor).

Whether or not the questioning seems tough, you can never be sure what a panel is thinking!
Etienne
Nibbles
Posts: 36
Joined: Fri Nov 28, 2008 5:30 pm

Post by Nibbles »

Hi,

Buckscat, Thanks for your kind words, good luck next week.

Etienne I hope you are right.

The Chairmans words 'haven't you got any more academic evidence - theres not much here' - or something to that effect I'm too traumatised to remember exactly are still ringing in my ears!!
All Too Much
Posts: 72
Joined: Mon Jan 12, 2009 3:29 pm

Similar experience on 14 Jan

Post by All Too Much »

Hi Nibbles

We also had our appeal yesterday and was asked the same - where is all the academic evidence?! We gave them everything we could find (and more) and the chairman just kept saying he couldn't see enough academic evidence. In there an hour - came out really down. Funny thing was during it the chairman mentioned that he didn't actually know what the 11+ papers consisted of i.e. a question paper and a separate answer sheet. This is the man who is going to deny our son a future. Does he have the right, considering he doesn't seem to have done his homework? Hated it; found it demeaning. Will never do it again.
All Too Much
Buckscat
Posts: 18
Joined: Mon Jan 12, 2009 2:41 pm

Post by Buckscat »

Sorry to hear you too had such a rough time AllTooMuch.....

Etienne/Sally Anne - a question, if you can help. What more can parents produce in the way of evidence than reports, SATs, schoolwork and strong recommendations from the school? I am tempted to just give up now since apart from the same kind of academic evidence, my daughter's ME and the manner in which the tests were conducted in our school I have nothing - and lower scores. :cry:

If it is true that the Chair didn't even know how the tests are done how can he sit on a Panel? Surely a basic understanding of what our children have gone through is essential.

Fingers crossed for you too AllTooMuch
Thanks

Catherine
panickingmum
Posts: 47
Joined: Sat Jan 10, 2009 6:12 pm
Location: Bucks

Oh Dear what can we do?

Post by panickingmum »

Hi to you both,

Best of luck for your results. It will be interesting to see how you both get on whether the panel were pushing for more because they didnt support you both or looking for chinks? Please let us know your results.

Either way this has got me really worried! Our appeal is next week and not feeling very positive at the moment anyway, but as my husband says we can only do our best!

Lots of luck,

PM
Nibbles
Posts: 36
Joined: Fri Nov 28, 2008 5:30 pm

Post by Nibbles »

Hi All Too Much,

I wonder if you had the same panel as us or is this a common response from other panels. Without giving too much away we were in the Civic Centre, where were you?

Hope you get a good result I am trying to remain positive.
All Too Much
Posts: 72
Joined: Mon Jan 12, 2009 3:29 pm

Post by All Too Much »

Hi Nibbles, yes, we were in the Civic Centre but were brought to an outside building, upstairs. 4 men and 1 woman altogether in room (apart from us!). Sound familiar?

All the best.
All Too Much
Post Reply